Subject: Today is the day EDA started to be a SNPS-CDNS duopoly -- or NOT
Today's the big day.
April 7 2010 - Carl Icahn starts secretly buying MENT shares.
May 27 2010 - Icahn tells the world he's buying MENT shares.
June 24 2010 - MENT board limits Icahn ownership to 15% max.
Feb 8 2011 - Icahn calls for the breaking up of MENT, proposes
selling MENT in parts to SNPS and CDNS.
Feb 11 2011 - Icahn nominates 3 hand-picked candidates to directly
replace 3 specific MENT board of directors.
Feb 22 2011 - Icahn bids $1.9 B (or $17 a share) to buy MENT.
Feb 24 2011 - MENT posts a profitible FY2010 with a record $915 M in
revenue, and with FY2011 predicted to be even better.
March 11 2011 - DeepChip survey in ESNUG 489 shows 88% of 307 MENT users
greatly fear a Synopsys-Cadence duopoly forming.
March 28 2011 - MENT board of directors rejects Icahn's $1.9 B bid
stating that "serious regulatory risks persist".
April 25 2011 - MENT publically dismisses Icahn's 3 board candidates.
May 2 2011 - ISS recommends 2 out of Carl Icahn's 3 board candidates.
Glass Lewis rejects all 3 of Icahn's 3 board candidates.
May 3 2011 - Egan-Jones rejects all 3 of Icahn's 3 board candidates.
May 5 3011 - MENT issues statement that the prelim Q1 results look
good with bookings up 7% over last year's Q1.
May 12 2011 - (today) The day of the MENT Annual Stockholder's Meeting.
This is the day where the results of the MENT board of directors election
comes out. It will go one of three ways:
- None of Icahn's candidates are elected. MENT continues on with
Wally Rhines at the helm and stays the #2 company in the EDA Big 3.
- Two or three of Icahn's candidates are elected to the 8 person MENT
board of directors. Internal strife eventually leads MENT to sell
off its parts to SNPS and CDNS. Icahn dances the happy dance.
- Two or three of Icahn's candidates are elected but they come to
realize that MENT is doing pretty damn well on its current course
under Wally. Carl Icahn has a public temper tantrum about MENT.
Any result that stops a SNPS-CDNS duopoly from forming is good news for all
EDA users. Otherwise, mediocre package deal tools, indifferent customer
support, and quiet price collusion for chip design SW will be the norm in
the not-too-distant future.... and today will be the day it all began.
- John Cooley
DeepChip.com Holliston, MA
|